A missing child, the botched case and the aunt who never stopped asking why
SOURCE:ABC Australia|BY:Maddison Connaughton
Fifty years after Beaumaris schoolgirl Eloise Worledge vanished, could new leads solve one of Australia's most haunting cold cases?
Fifty years after schoolgirl Eloise Worledge disappeared, could new leads solve one of Australia's most haunting cold cases?
In the back courtyard of a small cafe on Melbourne's grey seaside, a group of women have gathered around a long table. They have the place to themselves, and are locked in intense conversation about the past — the wild 70s, the end of the Whitlam era, when they were all young parents, living in a bayside hamlet called Beaumaris.
They are talking about a young girl who went missing back then, an eight-year-old named Eloise Worledge, who vanished one night in January 1976, just a short drive from where they all sit now. The case has since become infamous around this area, a whispered story of darkness beneath the suburban malaise.
Some of the women here speak like amateur sleuths, their voices bright with the hope that if they turn a fact of the disappearance this way or that, something new will reveal itself. But this is no true crime club.
Holding court at the centre of the table is Margie Thomas, sharp and serious, an air of Helen Garner about her. Eloise Worledge was her niece and goddaughter. And for nearly a half century, she's pushed for answers about what happened to her. This has, at times, stirred controversy, even within her own family — through which Eloise's disappearance has cleaved a deep scar.
For nearly half a century Margie Thomas has pushed for answers to what happened to her niece, Eloise.(ABC News: Daniella Bonica)
Most of the women at the table knew Eloise too, as Ella, the quiet eldest daughter of their good friend Patsy Worldege, who passed away a few years ago. They speak of her as gorgeous, a blunt fringe cut into her sandy blonde hair, and shy too, always trailing behind her younger sister.
"She was lovely," says Megan Walton, a close friend of Patsy's who had a son the same age. "She was never loud or aggressive or rude or naughty. She was just really sweet, gentle."
Eloise loved making art, like her mum, and was deeply bookish, like her dad. One friend remembers that a popular kids magazine Cricket, sometimes called the "the New Yorker for children", was her favourite.
"She loved to read, which is always a good thing for a child, I think," Margie says. "I loved being the auntie… We used to joke about it, you know, auntie is allowed to spoil, but the parents aren't."
Margie has convened this meeting as the 50th anniversary of Eloise's disappearance looms. She wants to organise a memorial to commemorate her niece's life in some formal way.
But she has another goal, too. She wants to try and push the police to investigate new leads that have emerged in the decades since her niece vanished. She wants justice, if such a thing is even possible in a case like this.
She tells the group that for the first time in decades the police have just summoned her to a meeting, and told her they have some news about the case that she'll want to hear.
Jane Mirvis was best friends with Eloise's mother, Patsy.(ABC News: Daniella Bonica)
Sitting quietly at one end of the table is Jane Mirvis. In her 80s, she's striking, impeccably put together, careful with her words. She was best friends with Eloise's mother Patsy and lived directly across the street from the Worledge home in the '70s.
She remembers, keenly, the day Eloise disappeared — she was in her front yard, around 8am, when an awful scream pierced the morning quiet. It was Patsy.
"Patsy came over and said, 'I can't find Ella,'" Jane recalls. While her friend, an artist, an extrovert, was prone to dramatic swings of emotion, this was on another level.
She followed Patsy back across the street — where their young children played together most days — to the Worledge's small weatherboard house.
"We got up and had a look and unfortunately her bike was there," Jane says. "Because otherwise I would've said, look, she's out riding the bike for sure."
Eloise had just gotten a bicycle for Christmas, a few weeks earlier, and in the long summer days since the eight-year-old had been riding it endlessly. But the bike was there, and she was not. She had disappeared from her bed in the night.
A drawing by Eloise.(Supplied)
'She's gone'
The morning of January 13 is burned in Margie's mind, too, from the moment she picked up the phone to hear her sister's panicked voice.
"She was hysterical," Margie says. "She couldn't find Ella. 'She's gone. Come 'round. Come 'round'."
It was a short drive, no more than a few minutes, but Margie says she sped over, still in her pyjamas and a dressing gown.
At the Worledge house, she found Patsy in a terrible state, shaking. Patsy's husband, Lindsay, was there too, seemingly stunned. Though he was always far more reserved than his wife, he was never one to be lost for words. Jane was sitting at the dining table, with Eloise's two younger siblings, Anna and Blake.
"Lindsay had called Beaumaris Police Station, and there was no sign of the policeman there," Margie recalls. So, she dialled the emergency line and handed the phone to him.
He told them: "My house has been broken into overnight and the only thing missing is my eight-year-old daughter".
Years later, the police operator would remark that this call stuck in his mind more than any other he received. The lack of emotion the caller displayed shocked him, given the gravity of the crime being reported.
Lindsay was still on the phone to police when the local sergeant, Cyril Wilson, finally arrived at the house.
"Have you searched the house?" Wilson asked them all. "Children don't just disappear."
He was nonchalant, shockingly so considering what was to come, but this reflected just how unfathomable a crime like this was for this time, for this place.
"That was really why I liked this area because it was so quiet and it was feeling very safe," Jane says.
Beaumaris was a pretty isolated place, she says, without even a train station, where everyone knew their neighbours. Kids would roam from house-to-house in the afternoons, told only to be home by dinner. Parents worried about their wallet getting snatched at the beach, not their children vanishing.
Eloise Worledge with her sibling and friends. (Supplied: Megan Walton)
With the clarity of hindsight though, some are angry about the way the case was treated in those vital first hours.
"The local policeman was just appalling when you think what he did tramping around and, you know, dropping cigarette butts and all the rest," Jane says.
For Margie, too, this remains a sore point. "The crime scene was basically walked all over… Nothing was fenced off."
More police units soon pulled up to the Worledge house, both uniformed and plain-clothes. John Bodinnar was among them.
"I was a detective senior constable at the Moorabbin CIB [criminal investigation bureau]," he recalls. "I was 27. An enthusiastic young guy with brown hair, not grey."
He'd been working in the area for a few years and always found it pretty sleepy. "We had a lot of shoplifting," he says. "We had a lot of petty crime, and we had a lot of crime committed by children."
The young detective had never gotten a call like this one before.
Something's wrong here
Lindsay Worledge, his face dominated by square eyeglasses beneath bushy eyebrows, met Bodinnar and his partner at the door. Patsy, slim and tanned, her hair with its distinctive pageboy cut, appeared behind her husband.
Bodinnar says they were shown to Eloise's room, where the bedclothes were mussed, as if someone had slept there and thrown covers back to get up in the morning.
The thing that wrenched the detectives' attention though was the fly screen covering the window right next to the single bed. The metal mesh had been cut, or ripped, and rolled up into the room. The window was wound open to its widest point. There were a few pieces of tanbark on the ground, too.
It was immediately clear to Bodinnar that this wasn't a kid who'd run away, this was an abduction.
He recalls his partner turning to him. "He told me to go out and tell Sergeant Wilson to wait at the front door and not touch anything, but that was too late," he says. "He'd already touched everything."
The police separated the parents and began trying to establish a timeline of what happened in the hours before Eloise vanished.
Patsy said that she'd left home after dinner the night before for her weekly jazz ballet class, at a church hall just a few minutes' walk from the house. Afterwards, she'd popped into Jane's place for a drink. When she got back home, Lindsay was watching TV. She told the police that she checked on the children before going to sleep, and all of them, including Eloise, were in their beds.
Clipping from The Age newspaper in 2003.(Supplied)
For his part Lindsay, a university lecturer, told the detectives he'd spent the afternoon drinking with colleagues before getting home around 5:30pm. He'd played Monopoly with the children and then watched TV, and made some phone calls, before going to bed just before midnight.
Neither could remember if they'd closed the front door, let alone locked it.
Both said the first sign anything was wrong only came the next morning when their young son, playing at the end of their bed, told them Ella wasn't in her room. Neither paid much mind to this at first. But then they saw the cut flyscreen.
Bodinnar recalls that the mood with the parents was strange.
"No one was crying, screaming, 'Look, do something, find our daughter.' None of that. No tears," he says. "I formed an opinion that something's wrong here."
The search for Eloise quickly ballooned into the largest ever launched by Victoria Police.(Supplied)
Lindsay and Patsy admitted to the police that their marriage was in a state of collapse, it had been for a long time. They put it down to incompatibility. He was an introvert, cerebral, with few friends. She was gregarious, voraciously social, highly strung — and she'd grown tired of her husband's vicious verbal put-downs.
After months of shrugging it off, Lindsay had finally made arrangements to move out of the family home. The day before Eloise disappeared, he'd had an appointment booked to sign a rental agreement for an apartment, only to reschedule at the last minute, moving it to the 13th. This, among other things, aroused suspicion.
In those first hours, Bodinnar says, the case felt solvable. But when he returned to the Worledge home in the afternoon, he says he found the scene completely transformed.
"There were police everywhere… There were TV crews there," he says. "And as soon as they knew the TV channels were there, and that they were making a big deal out of it, all the top brass decided they should have their face in it, so they went down."
Margie felt this shift, too.
"That's when I really knew it was serious when they arrived. Because it wasn't just the local police," she says. "It got very big, very fast. I remember being in the car… and seeing the photo, the school photo of Eloise, on the billboard outside all the newsagents."
The search for Eloise quickly ballooned into the largest ever launched by Victoria Police. More than 200 personnel converged on the small beachside suburb, commandeering the local high school for search headquarters.
Officers were dispatched to trawl the vast parks and sports reserves in the area, and its scrubby foreshore, thick with gnarled tea trees. Going door-to-door, they searched properties and questioned locals. Quite a few neighbours reported hearing a prowler in the area on the night of the disappearance.
Tips poured in from across the country, and around the world.
A police officer investigating Eloise's disappearance believed "somethings wrong here".(Supplied)
The first mistake
But senior police who worked the case back then now believe that going so wide, so quickly was likely a misstep — that resources should've been concentrated closer to home. Some worry things were missed.
There are locals, who lived right nearby, who still puzzle over why they were never spoken to during the search, despite police claiming they doorknocked 6,000 homes.
Rob Walton was a friend of Patsy, and is the sole man sitting around the table at Margie's meeting. He recalls that a colleague of his who lived minutes from the Worledges and owned a VW campervan — a vehicle flagged as of interest by investigators — wasn't even questioned about it.
There was a sense of frenzy in the early investigation, Walton says. One day he arrived at the Worledge house and was quickly put to work by police manning the phone, with no vetting and no instructions.
"It was very chaotic. The phone was not far inside the front door and so a lot of people were coming and going behind my back," he says. Because of the media, strangers were calling the house, crank calls, and a surprising number of older women who told him, "I've had a dream, she's gone to God."
He didn't think to take notes, no one had told him to. "That's how naive I was, really," he says.
But his wife, Megan, reflects that, at the time, everyone in Patsy's circle believed Eloise would be back within days.
"I don't think we ever thought that we'd never see her again," she says. "I don't even know whether we maybe thought it was Lindsay, let's say, but that down the track, all of that would be resolved."
Other friends speculated similarly, in the rare quiet moments — that Lindsay had taken Eloise as some ploy to stall the implosion of his marriage. But they thought that meant she was safe. Eloise didn't come home though, and her father always denied any involvement. And despite all the intense police resources, and white-hot media focus, the investigation soon stalled.
In late January of that year, forensic examiner Geoff Le Couter was asked to re-examine the scene at the Worledge home. His superiors wanted to know if the original forensic team had missed anything, particularly when it came to the window with the slashed flyscreen.
Strikingly tall, Le Couter has a careful manner, most comfortable talking facts, figures and specifics.
"The window was one that you could wind out… there's a chain and you can open the window but only so far. But on this one you were able to disengage that [chain] and actually widen the window," he recalls. "Around the window there was a flyscreen and that fly wire had been cut and a part of it had been torn."
How the flyscreen in Eloise's bedroom was slashed and why was a mystery to investigators.(Facebook: Eloise Worledge - Missing Person Australia)
It was determined this tear was likely made accidentally by local police when first searching the scene. But using a powerful microscope they borrowed from RMIT university, forensic tests revealed that the cut was made by a blade, with red paint on it, potentially a pair of scissors.
Even decades later, how the sound of this woke no one in the night remains a mystery to Le Couter.
But he and his colleague Robert Brown found something else while they were searching the house — a letter among Eloise's things, addressed to her.
Brown described the letter as being some 10-20 lines in length with "strong religious overtones" that referred to her being "saved". He handed it to investigators. But it seems to have then been dismissed by detectives as insignificant. Brown believed they told him the letter was from an uncle in the United Kingdom. Yet Eloise didn't have an uncle in the UK.
Eloise Worledge disappeared from her Beaumaris home in 1976. (Supplied: Margie Thomas )
"On face value it was really quite important," Le Couter says, unsure of why it was discounted. This letter appears to have been lost in the decades since.
Le Couter's work on the window, though, did have an immediate impact on the case. Because he and Brown determined that the flyscreen had, in all likelihood, not been cut from the outside but from inside Eloise's bedroom.
The dust on the windowsill was untouched, and cobwebs still hung between the opened window and its frame, which meant it was unlikely the window had been opened further than its chain. How the screen had been cut and rolled up would have been very difficult to do from the outside with so little space.
This all added up to one thing.
"It was more probable that the child was not taken out through the window," Le Couter says. "It'd been staged."
It seems someone had wanted to make it look like Eloise was taken out the window. But the evidence showed she was probably carried right out the front door.
Rumours, an affair, leads that went nowhere
This finding swung even more intense focus onto Eloise's parents and their circle. Salacious rumours swirled that Lindsay and Patsy were swingers, something friends say wasn't really the case. But it did emerge that Patsy had been having an affair, for months, with an associate of Lindsay's, a man named Noel Anthony.
Many in Patsy's sprawling friendship circle were questioned. Police quizzed Margie on her relationships with men, her friendship with Lindsay, and asked her straight out if the two of them had taken Eloise.
" I didn't have a problem saying, no, I hadn't done it," she says. "I didn't get shirty about it at all. It just seemed, to me, strange. I think they were genuinely looking and didn't have anyone really in mind."
A front-page story from the week of the disappearance. (Supplied)
Jane remembers being driven into police headquarters in Melbourne for an interview. "There was another friend ... myself and Patsy were all taken into Russell Street and questioned," she says.
She recalls police telling them, separately, that the others had confessed, just to see their reaction. "We actually heard Patsy screaming, literally screaming," she says, "saying, 'Really don't be so ridiculous.'"
The police later placed Patsy and Jane in a room together, secretly recording them. But once alone, all they did was complain about the police's manner, and puzzle over the facts of the case.
By February that year, police were left with just a handful of leads that went nowhere. Among them, multiple sightings of young men acting strangely around the Worledge home on the night of Eloise's disappearance and of a suspicious green 1966 Holden station wagon seen on the street.
Also the sound of a car door slamming at around 2am on January 13, 1976, reported by two separate neighbours mere metres from the Worledge house. One was also sure she heard a child cry out at the same time.
Just over a month after Eloise's disappearance, the investigating taskforce was disbanded. The detective in charge told the media: "We have exhausted all the avenues open to us. And there are more pressing problems to deal with."
The circus moved on, and eventually the public did too. While locals say this was the end of a sort of innocence — of unlocked front doors and kids playing in the street until dusk — the reality is that to most, in time, Eloise became a ghost story.
It was her family who was left to reckon with the reality of her loss, how to continue to live in the wake of something so shattering.
There's a photo of Patsy in April 1976 from an interview she did with the Australian Women's Weekly. In it, she's sitting on Eloise's bed, the sheets still stripped for forensic testing. She looks like the survivor of some terrible accident, dazed, amidst the wreckage.
"My main fear is that people will forget," she told the magazine. "If they do, Ella will never be found."
Patsy Worledge in the Australian Women's Weekly.(Australian Women's Weekly: Don McPhedran)
Lindsay and Patsy separated officially in the months after Eloise's disappearance. Both went on to marry others. They faced another shared tragedy two decades later, when their son Blake was killed in a car accident.
Lindsay died in 2017, and Patsy a few years later, in 2022. She told reporters, before she passed, that she'd been able to find some sense of peace with Eloise's loss.
For a long time after Eloise vanished, Margie says she felt that she couldn't even move house.
"Because if I wasn't there… she wouldn't know where I was," she says. "And so, I stayed there and stayed there and stayed there because I thought, if she comes here, then I'll be there."
A bombshell revelation
Years passed, decades, without any word. Until in 2021, news broke of shocking crimes committed at Beaumaris Primary School, where Eloise had been a student, about to start Year 4, when she disappeared.
Immediately, locals wondered if there might be some connection with Eloise's disappearance. They point out that one of the most high-profile victims, footballer Rod Owen, was in Eloise's year at school.
The school wasn't an angle that was ever canvassed in the original investigation. John Bodinnar says that, to his knowledge, police in Beaumaris didn't know about these teachers when he was working in the area, despite the fact parents had complained about some of them to the school.
"There was no hint of any of these paedophiles at the local school," he says. "It is certainly relevant given that it transpired at the time of Eloise's disappearance."
A state inquiry set up to examine the school abuse did briefly broach the question of Eloise Worledge. But it reported the information presented "did not reveal any connection between Eloise's disappearance and the matters within the scope of the terms of reference".
Margie's aunt has stayed close to the case for five decades.(ABC News: Danielle Bonica)
David MacGregor, one of the abusive teachers eyed by the Beaumaris Inquiry, was interviewed by police during a reinvestigation of the Eloise Worledge case during the early 2000s.
A friend of his, another local man named Alistair Webster, who ran Beaumaris' junior soccer club, was also interviewed.
A parent at Beaumaris Primary, Webster had a significant rap sheet, which included sexual abuse.
Rob Walton knew both MacGregor and Webster through the junior soccer club and says he was shocked to learn of their crimes.
The two men, he says, " were poles apart as personalities".
"[MacGregor] was the original mild mannered Mr King, you know… he'd come to soccer practice with all the soccer nets to put up and the balls and the flags and things. And he was very personable and not very forthcoming," he says. Webster, on the other hand, was a stern Scotsman, soccer-obsessed.
The reinvestigation did not find any evidence linking these men to Eloise Worledge’s disappearance. In fact, it didn't yield any new leads at all. And in 2003, a coroner ruled that Eloise had likely died, but could not make any findings about what happened to her.
For Margie, the question of whether Eloise's disappearance could be linked to her primary school is a difficult one to consider. She's found herself turning over memories, trying to pinpoint whether there was any change in Eloise's behaviour before she disappeared. Even small things, like her niece's habit of biting her nails, can seem like a clue.
"I used to joke about it and say, give me a taste, you know, a nibble, you'd have a laugh about it," Margie recalls. But really, she says, there's nothing that stands out.
Yet she believes that police need to look more seriously at the school, whether there is any connection, even if it's a painful territory.
"This is part of the picture, and we cannot, not think about it and we have to investigate it," she says. "I've got to think down those lines now. We can't just dismiss it. It was happening at the school."
Living with loss, and memories
As the 50th anniversary of Eloise Worledge's disappearance approaches, Margie is busying herself with memorial planning. She wants to have the service at Beaumaris beach, where she last remembers spending a lazy, sunny afternoon with Eloise, just before that fateful night.
The memorial will be the first time she's ever formally marked her niece's disappearance; the grief has almost been held in suspended animation. By now though, the little girl would be nearing 60. She would've lived a whole life.
Margie stumbles a little, thinking of what she wishes she could tell Eloise. "I still love her," she says, eventually. "And that I'm sorry that we weren't able to find her."
Margie wants to see the reward for information raised.(ABC News: Daniella Bonica)
Meanwhile, there has been some movement on her other goal, to spur Victoria Police into reanimating this investigation. In December, she had her meeting with the Missing Persons Squad to talk about Eloise's case.
There, a detective told her something that shocked her.
"He said that they've come to the conclusion that Patsy and Lindsay were not involved, which is pretty monumental," Margie says.
But in the wake of this revelation, one question is thrown into even sharper relief: If not Eloise's parents, then who?
Victoria Police say the investigation into Eloise's disappearance "remains active and ongoing" and confirm no evidence implicating Lindsay or Patsy Worledge in the crime has ever been found.
Margie says she wants the police to raise the reward for information about Eloise's disappearance. It has sat at $10,000 since it was first offered in 1976.
She thinks something like that could draw out people who have information that hasn't yet surfaced.
"Someone who might have been thinking for a while, you know, 'I've been thinking about this. Oh, I didn't bother telling you. It's only so small,' " she says. "There may be pieces of the jigsaw puzzle they might be able to fit together."
"Every case and therefore every reward strategy is different. Often we only get one chance to announce a reward and so we have to ensure we make the best use of the announcement," a Victoria Police spokesperson told the ABC. "Each case is assessed on its merits and it is our utmost desire, in every case, to get the information we need and solve it."
They added that police remain hopeful the case can be solved if the right information would come to light.
This is Margie's hope too, that there's still someone alive who knows the full truth of what happened to her niece, and that they are finally willing to tell it.