Atletico 1 Real Madrid 2: Valverde's stunner, Alonso's job and Vinicius Jr's spat with Simeone
SOURCE:The Athletic|BY:Dermot Corrigan and more
Xabi Alonso's side scraped through to Sunday's Supercopa de Espana final against Barcelona
Real Madrid sealed their progress to Sunday’s Supercopa de Espana final against Barcelona by beating Atletico Madrid 2-1 in a tense derby in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.
Federico Valverde put Real ahead after less than two minutes with a rocket of a free kick from distance. Atletico goalkeeper Jan Oblak saved from Rodrygo in the 28th minute, but Real’s lead began to look shaky — Thibaut Courtois was forced to deny Alexander Sorloth in the 33rd minute from a corner, before Sorloth glanced a header over the bar with the goal at his mercy two minutes later.
Rodrygo gave his team breathing space in the 55th minute when he shook off Robin Le Normand and finished past Oblak following a fine pass from Valverde. But Sorloth cut that lead down three minutes later with a header from close range from a Giuliano Simeone cross.
Real held on despite some late scares — meaning Alonso has the chance to challenge for a first trophy in charge of Real against Barca.
Here, Dermot Corrigan and Anantaajith Raghuraman analyse the key talking points.
Valverde’s bolt from the blue
A minute in, Real Madrid used a strategy that became their go-to for much of the first half. They lumped the ball long to Gonzalo Garcia, with Jude Bellingham picking up his knock-down, before the England midfielder was brought down by Conor Gallagher. It looked like a soft foul, with some camera angles hinting that Bellingham may have made contact with Gallagher first.
In most games, that would have been an innocuous moment, but Valverde made it memorable. He sprinted in and thumped a finish from around 30 yards out that took a minor deflection off Alexander Sorloth and went in off Oblak’s fingertips. This was as clean a dead-ball strike as you are likely to see.
Valverde’s goal took all of 76 seconds, the earliest goal in the Supercopa this century, surpassing Mario Mandzukic, who scored after 82 seconds for Atletico in Alonso’s final game as a player for Real in August 2014. Valverde’s goal was also the fourth-earliest Real strike against Atletico in the 21st century.
Valverde’s celebration was just as striking, with the Uruguay international roaring and hitting his head with both hands as he ran off. It was a moment of release. This season, the midfielder has played in his less-preferred position at right-back and been forced to defend himself from criticism on social media.
Madrid’s captain made an important contribution in defence too, with some well-timed slide tackles and a couple of interceptions. Valverde also provided the key pass for Rodrygo’s effort to make it 2-0. He remains indispensable to a side still attempting to find their identity under Alonso.
In the continuing emotional rollercoaster of Real Madrid’s season, there is one clear good news story over the last couple of months: the return to form and confidence of Rodrygo.
Last summer, it looked as if the Brazil forward would leave the Bernabeu. He started the campaign mostly on the bench and his performances during his few appearances did not suggest he should be part of Alonso’s long-term plans.
That all changed in early December with a Champions League game against Manchester City, when Rodrygo was given a surprise start and scored an excellent goal — his first in 32 games — running to celebrate with Alonso in a clear show of support for the under-pressure coach.
Rodrygo celebrates his goal on Thursday (Jose Breton/Pics Action/NurPhoto via Getty Images)
Madrid lost that game 2-1, but he followed it up with a late winner at Alaves in La Liga that possibly saved Alonso from the sack, then added four assists in Madrid’s wins against Sevilla and Real Betis either side of the winter break.
It has been quite the turnaround, with Rodrygo playing with much more confidence and purpose than he previously showed. That sharpness was evident in how he took his goal tonight — racing onto Valverde’s pass, skipping past Le Normand, and slotting past Oblak.
There was a scare for him and Madrid when it looked like Rodrygo had been injured soon after scoring. The 24-year-old recovered, but he is a doubt for Sunday’s final with a leg issue. Alonso will desperately hope he is available given his recent form.
Madrid may have won this game, but it leaves Alonso with more questions than answers about a defence that has kept two clean sheets in their last 11 matches across all competitions.
Atletico dominated the first half following Valverde’s early strike, regularly prising gaps in Madrid’s shape as they dropped deeper and deeper. Julian Alvarez could collect the ball between the lines on the half-turn, with him and Alex Baena spreading the play out wide and slipping players in behind. Madrid’s back line were forced to repel multiple crosses, while Courtois saved from Baena (twice) and Sorloth.
Madrid scored early in the second half too, through Rodrygo’s excellent finish. They still could not tighten up at the back, though, conceding just three minutes later. A simple exchange between Marcos Llorente and Simeone saw the former slip the latter in behind a static Vinicius Junior, circled in red below.
Left-back Alvaro Carreras could not get out in time to stop Simeone’s cross, which Sorloth headed in.
Courtois made another save from Sorloth at his near post before Madrid’s defence were plunged into more problems. Alonso substituted Antonio Rudiger — who was an injury doubt heading into the match — and Raul Asencio in the 69th minute, with the latter looking disappointed on the bench.
On came Ferland Mendy and Fran Garcia in their place. That left Madrid with a back line consisting of two left-backs (Carreras and Mendy) and two midfielders (Aurelien Tchouameni and Valverde).
Atletico missed a few good chances in the final minutes, with Madrid continuing to struggle with blindside runs. Tchouameni made a crucial block to deny Antoine Griezmann from running onto a good cross from the right, too.
That helped Alonso’s side seal the win, but Barcelona will pose harder questions in the final, especially if they continue to suffer the same problems in defence.
Anantaajith Raghuraman
Where does this leave Alonso?
Real Madrid achieved their main objective of qualifying for Sunday’s Clasico final against Barcelona, but this was far from a total success for Alonso and his team.
After taking an early lead, they never really pushed forward to build on that advantage and control the game, and there was more relief than joy when the final whistle confirmed their narrow victory.
Over the 90 minutes, there were few signs of the high-tempo, high pressing, modern vertical football that made Alonso’s Leverkusen side so impressive — the style he planned to instil into this Madrid squad when he was appointed in May.
Instead, Madrid’s football was again disjointed and scrappy, especially in midfield, where Bellingham had some bright moments early on, but there was little control or cohesion. The team’s collective defending was also poor, even before they lost both centre-backs through injury.
Xabi Alonso remains in a tricky position at Real Madrid (Jose Hernandez/Anadolu via Getty Images)
Alonso’s team have now won five consecutive games, but this has generally been down to individual quality and moments of magic from their top players — tonight it was Valverde’s piledriver and Rodrygo’s excellently taken second goal. They also still rely heavily on Courtois’ excellence in goal.
Madrid’s overall performance was definitely better than their dismal showing in September’s 5-2 ‘derbi’ defeat to Atletico, which arguably counts as progress under their new coach. But there is still no proper feeling that this is Alonso’s Madrid — and doubts as to when it will ever be. Whether Alonso actually has the squad to play the way he wants remains an open question. Injuries in defence have not helped either.
At Real Madrid, the coach generally pays for bad results, no matter the circumstances.
So Sunday’s Supercopa final against a Barcelona team who appear in much better form will be another huge test. Alonso needs a convincing performance as well as a trophy, or the speculation over how long he will last as Madrid coach will continue.
Dermot Corrigan
What happened between Vinicius Jr and Simeone?
An intriguing subplot throughout tonight’s game was what appeared to be a running feud between Vinicius Jr and Atletico coach Diego Simeone.
At one moment during the first half, Simeone appeared to say, “They’re going to get rid of you, don’t forget that I told you,” based on images from Spanish broadcaster Movistar TV.
The most heated moment came when Vinicius Jr was substituted on 81 minutes, and whistles rang around the Alinma Stadium. Another replay shown on Movistar TV appeared to show a smiling Simeone pointing to his ear to tell the Brazil forward to listen to the noise being aimed at him.
Diego Simeone and Vinicius Junior clash on the touchline (Yasser Bakhsh/Getty Images)
An upset-looking Vinicius Jr replied with some words of his own to the Atletico coach on the sideline. Alonso left his technical area to pull his player away, and then looked to continue the conversation himself with his Atletico counterpart. Replays on Movistar appeared to show Alonso saying “Cholo, just worry about your own” to Simeone and also telling referee Mateo Busquets Ferrer “he shouldn’t be talking to our players”.
Staff from both clubs became involved in a mini-scuffle, with Simeone exchanging words with Valverde, before the Argentine coach was shown a yellow card.
Dermot Corrigan
What did Simeone say?
When asked in his post-match press conference about the exact nature of his words to Vinicius Jr, Simeone said with a smile: “I don’t remember, my memory is not great.”
“I always say, since I was a player, what happens on the pitch stays on the pitch. So nothing to say,” he added to Movistar.
“Julian had a chance, Alex (Sorloth) too in the first half with a header, Baena (with) another that Courtois saved really well. Marcos (Llorente) had one from outside the box. (There was) a last cross which we could not get on the end of. We can say we played well, made chances. They were not better than us, but they have won.”
What did Alonso say?
“I don’t like what happened in that moment,” Alonso told Movistar, when asked about the touchline spat following Vinicius Jr’s substitution.
“I saw that El Cholo said something to him. For me, this type of thing crosses the line of respect for a fellow professional. I don’t like when anyone says things like that to my team-mates. I always try and show respect to the opposition players. Not everything goes.
“It is a semi-final, and having scored early gave us an advantage that you want to defend. There were phases when we had to defend for long periods, but the objective was progressing to the final. We have achieved that. The team knew how to hang in there, the substitutes also did well, so we are happy to be in Sunday’s final.”
Madrid fear Rudiger will be unavailable for the final and said Asencio and Rodrygo were both “reasonable doubts” depending on the outcome of tests on Friday. Sources close to Asencio’s camp, who asked to remain anonymous to protect relationships, insisted the Spaniard would be available to play against Barcelona.
Alonso also confirmed that Kylian Mbappe, who has been out with a knee injury, would travel to be with the team on Friday. The Athletic reported earlier this week that, despite being initially left out of the Supercopa squad, Mbappe had not been ruled out for any potential final.
“He’s much better, he has trained and the feelings are good,” Alonso said. “The possibilities (for him to play) are the same as the rest.”