Premier League transfers: Ranking the impact made by all 155 summer signings
SOURCE:The Athletic|BY:Tim Spiers
Which players have exceeded expectations and which ones have yet to deliver? We re-assess the summer transfers as the January window opens
Bing-bong. Happy New Year, the winter transfer window is here! Congratulations to all who celebrate.
To mark the re-opening of the market, we thought we’d revive an article which generated such an incredibly warm reaction in the comments section last time around; yes, ranking the impact made by all 155 Premier League summer signings!
We did it in September, we did it in October, and if you didn’t think we were going to do it in January, well, you really don’t know us that well at all.
Basically, it’s the 155 signings made by the 20 Premier League clubs in summer 2025, judged on their impact. This is not, repeat not, a list of players in order of exactly how good they’ve been overall… it’s a weighted power ranking based on how impactful each individual has been for his new club.
For example, the standard of technical football Burnley’s Zian Flemming has produced this season has been nowhere near that of, say, Noni Madueke at Arsenal (sorry, Zian) but you should see his goals-per-minute ratio.
Our list also isn’t about how good said signing is going to be next season, or five years from now… it’s purely based on the impact they’ve made in the past four and a bit months.
Some haven’t scored since we published our previous version of this list and have tailed off dramatically, some have done the exact opposite (clue, a sometime male-model living in Leeds), and some have seen injury curtail their season, but all will be judged.
So stick the kettle on, grab a mince pie if there are any left, sit back and, if you’re a Sunderland fan, make sure you keep on scrolling. Aston Villa supporters won’t have to scroll as far.
155. Harvey Elliott, Liverpool to Aston Villa
October rating: 108
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:Considered by many to be worth more than the fringe role he was given at Liverpool last season, it’s now time for Elliott to step up.
What we’re saying now: The only place Elliott has stepped up to is the under-21s (this isn’t true, as he hasn’t played for them either). What an abhorrent signing this has turned out to be. Did Villa not consult with their manager before signing Elliott? Unai Emery clearly doesn’t rate him and now an agreement may be reached to cart him back to Anfield in January. A shambolic situation.
154. Marc Guiu, Chelsea to Sunderland
October rating: 155
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:It was good while it lasted… Guiu was recalled to the mothership after just over three weeks. Thanks for the memories.
What we’re saying now: After it initially looked like his recall was a waste of time for everyone involved, Guiu has played more often for Chelsea of late, even scoring against Ajax in the Champions League.
153. Cuiabano, Botafogo to Nottingham Forest
October rating: 154
Reported transfer fee: £5million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:An attacking 22-year-old left-back who adds to Forest’s Brazilian cohort.
What we’re saying now: Was immediately loaned back to Botafogo until the winter window. Set to return to the City Ground from Rio de Janeiro for January.
152. Marcus Bettinelli, Chelsea to Manchester City
What we’re saying now: Well, yep, as expected, no appearances yet for the 33-year-old Scott Carson regen, but he has at least been on the bench for every one of City’s Champions League matches, but only because more substitutes can be named in Europe and Pep Guardiola has named two goalkeepers on his subs list.
151. Dario Essugo, Sporting CP to Chelsea
October rating: 151
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £18.5million
Contract length: Eight years
What we said then:A 20-year-old defensive midfielder who will likely provide backup to Moises Caicedo for the time being, but yet to feature having had surgery on a thigh injury.
What we’re saying now: Returned to training in November, only to suffer a setback.
150. Kota Takai, Kawasaki Frontale to Tottenham Hotspur
October rating: 149
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £5million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Promising 6ft 4in (193cm) Japanese centre-back whose fee is a record for a homegrown player leaving the J-League. The 20-year-old is currently around Spurs’ first-team squad, covering for long-term injury absentee Radu Dragusin, but will likely head out on loan before long.
What we’re saying now: Was in the matchday squad for the first time at Crystal Palace last week and could make his debut soon with Spurs’ fixtures piling up.
149. Tom King, Wolverhampton Wanderers to Everton
October rating: 148
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: Nominal
Contract length: Two years
What we said then:King of putting the cones out, right? Warmed the bench for two Carabao Cup games, but Everton are out of that competition now. Training standards: unknown.
What we’re saying now: King has actually been in a number of Premier League squads, but only because Everton’s injury issues have led to David Moyes naming two goalkeepers on the bench.
148. Angus Gunn, Norwich City to Forest
October rating: 147
Transfer fee: Free
Contract length: One year
What we said then:Championship-standard goalkeeper moves to Premier League club for a nice payday as a non-playing third-choice. Great to have around the dressing room, etc. Very much the No 3 behind Matz Sels and John Victor.
What we’re saying now: Exactly as above.
147. Adam Aznou, Bayern Munich to Everton
October rating: 146
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £7.8m
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Attack-minded, ball-carrying Moroccan teenage left-back. He’s only just turned 19, so is likely to be one for the future.
What we’re saying now: Perennial bench-warmer in the Premier League, with his only appearances coming in the EFL Trophy and National League Cup. One for a January loan?
146. Jonah Kusi-Asare, Bayern to Fulham
October rating: 150
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract Length: One year
What we said then:Hailed as the next Swedish wonderkid when he moved to Bayern from Stockholm’s AIK; 6ft 5in (195cm) striker Kusi-Asare has not made it onto the pitch yet despite a striker crisis at Fulham.
What we’re saying now: Five very brief substitute appearances totalling 40 minutes in what’s become an increasingly perplexing loan deal. You wouldn’t be surprised if Bayern recalled the 18-year-old in January.
145. Marcus Edwards, Sporting CP to Burnley
October rating: 143
Reported transfer fee: £8.5million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:His levels have dropped since he first made waves at Sporting. Did alright in the Championship (on loan to Burnley) last season but physicality is an issue.
What we’re saying now: Looks a threat when he does get on, but Scott Parker has used him sparingly, possibly thinking that Edwards isn’t up to the physical and/or defensive standards required.
144. Freddie Woodman, Preston North End to Liverpool
October rating: 141
Transfer fee: Free
Reported contract length: One year
What we said then:The 28-year-old has swapped weekly football in the Championship (37 league starts for Preston last time out) for what is effectively a season-ticket at Anfield. Nice work if you can get it.
What we’re saying now: Got his big chance at home against Crystal Palace in the Carabao Cup. Result? Nil-three. Oh.
143. Giovanni Leoni, Parma to Liverpool
October rating: 140
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £26million
Reported contract length: Six years
What we said then:Still a kid at 18, but this centre-back is already a giant at 6ft 4in (193cm). Suffered a devastating anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) knee injury on his debut in the Carabao Cup against Southampton. May not be seen again this season.
What we’re saying now: No updates yet on Leoni, whose long comeback continues.
Giovanni Leoni playing for Liverpool in September (Stu Forster/Getty Images)
142. Ben Gannon-Doak, Liverpool to Bournemouth
October rating: 90
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £25million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Given how raw and unproven he is at the top level, this is a bit of a gamble.
What we’re saying now: After four substitute appearances with Bournemouth, Gannon-Doak tore a hamstring playing for Scotland in November and has since undergone surgery. Will be sidelined for some time.
141. Jhon Arias, Fluminense to Wolves
October rating: 74
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £19million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:John to his mates. On his day, an exciting, game-changing forward, albeit one who won’t fill the departed Matheus Cunha’s boots in terms of end-product.
What we’re saying now: No goals and no assists from the Colombian’s 20 appearances represents a truly disastrous signing, especially given he, as Cunha’s replacement, was their most important addition of the summer. The standard-bearer for Wolves’ abysmal year of recruitment.
140. Max Weiss, Karlsruher to Burnley
October rating: 139
Reported transfer fee: £4.3m
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:An ever-present for a mid-table side in the German second division last season, 21-year-old Weiss offers a cheap, developing backup goalkeeper option at Turf Moor. Nutmegged for third-tier Cardiff’s winner in the Carabao Cup, a moment which means, barring injury, we won’t see him again until January.
What we’re saying now: Yep, still waiting.
139. Oleksandr Zinchenko, Arsenal to Forest
October rating: 114
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:The 28-year-old Ukrainian was left out of Forest’s squad for the league phase of the Europa League two days after signing. His two Premier League appearances were starts against Burnley and Sunderland and, well, he didn’t impress.
What we’re saying now: Rarely seen these days, as he clearly isn’t fancied by head coach Sean Dyche. Has also suffered with injuries, but generally he’s been bad. Very bad.
Zinchenko playing against Everton on Tuesday (David Davies/PA Images via Getty Images)
138. Antoni Milambo, Feyenoord to Brentford
October rating: 129
Reported fee: £20.25million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:The 20-year-old driving, attacking midfielder should fit in well in the Premier League with his pace, physicality and creativity.
What we’re saying now: Tore his anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) in October and won’t be seen again this season.
137. Reiss Nelson, Arsenal to Brentford
October rating: 117
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:It still feels like Nelson is a youngster, but he’s 26 in December and, after a bit-part role at Fulham on loan last season (two goals and an assist in 572 minutes of game time), it’s now-or-never time to really make an impact in the Premier League.
What we’re saying now: A low-risk addition on loan, but this move hasn’t worked out in the slightest. Just 32 minutes of football in the Premier League.
136. James Trafford, Burnley to Manchester City
October rating: 138
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £27million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:A howler or two and Trafford was unceremoniously dumped in favour of fellow summer signing Gianluigi Donnarumma. A great No 2 for City, but this isn’t what Trafford needs in his career right now.
What we’re saying now: City’s Carabao Cup goalkeeper for now, with a two-leg semi-final against Newcastle United on the horizon. His only other appearance since October came in the Champions League against Bayer Leverkusen, a game City lost 2-0. Has he made the right move?
Trafford warming up for City (Barrington Coombs/PA Images via Getty Images)
135. Igor Julio, Brighton & Hove Albion to West Ham United
October rating: 134
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:Surplus to requirements at Brighton but fills a need at West Ham to replace the departing Nayef Aguerd. The 27-year-old is a strength-in-depth signing if ever there was one.
What we’re saying now: A few appearances here and there, but not been able to convince new head coach Nuno Espirito Santo he’s worthy of a starting spot.
134. Fer Lopez, Celta Vigo to Wolves
October rating: 58
Reported transfer fee: £21.3million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Wolves have taken a bit of a gamble on the inexperienced 21-year-old attacking midfielder – could be incredible, could be a flop.
What we’re saying now: Not exactly a flop, but it’s become abundantly clear Lopez is definitely not ready for the Premier League. While his technique is lovely, physicality is a real issue. Wolves needed someone for the here and now, not the future, making this a bad signing so far.
133. Sebastiaan Bornauw, Wolfsburg to Leeds United
October rating: 136
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £5.2million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then: Belgian big boy Bornauw (6ft 3in/191cm) comes via a cheap fee. Very likely to just be a squad player.
What we’re saying now: Just two Premier League minutes so far.
132. Mads Hermansen, Leicester City to West Ham
October rating: 98
Reported transfer fee: Around £20million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:You question how great West Ham’s need for a new goalkeeper was. Conceded 11 goals in his opening four appearances, including a couple of wafty howlers, before being dropped by Graham Potter. Alphonse Areola is now back as No 1.
What we’re saying now: Not played a minute for them since Nuno’s September appointment.
131. Merlin Rohl, Freiburg to Everton
October rating: 135
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:With a name like that, you’d surely have to be a dinky, creative, wizard-like winger, but Rohl is actually a 6ft 3in (192cm) central midfielder. Injuries would be a concern, but this is a beefing-up-the-squad signing.
What we’re saying now: The least impactful of Everton’s outfield signings but has been hampered by injury and fitness issues. Made his first start against Nottingham Forest this week and will look to kick on now.
130. Loum Tchaouna, Lazio to Burnley
October rating: 93
Reported transfer fee: £12.9million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:A 21-year-old winger/forward who has played for France at five youth levels. He does have pace, but this is a real punt. An encouraging start but his quality is still in question.
What we’re saying now: Scored a worldie against Leeds in October, but that’s about it.
129. Mark Travers, Bournemouth to Everton
October rating: 133
Reported transfer fee: £4million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:The 26-year-old isn’t going to usurp England’s No 1 Jordan Pickford. Standard No 2 goalkeeper stuff: two Carabao Cup appearances, now waiting for the FA Cup to start in a week or so.
What we’re saying now: Tick-tock, it’s almost FA Cup o’clock.
128. Bashir Humphreys, Chelsea to Burnley
October rating: 142
Reported transfer fee: £14.7million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Nice to see an old-school surname back in the top flight. A centre-back who can also play at left wing-back, he’s a solid addition to the squad but out with a thigh injury.
What we’re saying now: Finally made his full Premier League debut against Everton last week and put in a great performance to help earn a clean sheet. Should get a run in their team now, fitness permitting.
127. James Justin, Leicester to Leeds
October rating: 128
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £10million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Literal one-time England international who has lost his way in recent seasons following ACL and Achilles injuries in 2020 and 2021 respectively, hence the relatively low fee.
What we’re saying now: Been the backup to Jayden Bogle at full-back/wing-back, with his 160 minutes coming over nine league appearances, often to help see games out.
Justin is struggling for game-time at Leeds (Rene Nijhuis/MB Media/Getty Images)
126. Tommy Watson, Sunderland to Brighton
October rating: 70
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £10million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:A 19-year-old with the world at his feet, with those feet being at the end of a lanky, gangly, dribbling maestro. Three assists in one Carabao Cup match against Barnsley showed his tremendous potential.
What we’re saying now: Hampered by a series of frustrating injuries.
125. Armando Broja, Chelsea to Burnley
October rating: 127
Reported transfer fee: £20million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:It’s pretty hard to make a case for Broja being the striker to fire promoted Burnley to top-flight safety, given his record in the past three completed seasons for Chelsea and during loans to Everton and Fulham is three goals in 58 appearances. That’s not a typo.
What we’re saying now: He scored a goal! Just the one, mind, but it did earn Burnley a point against Bournemouth just before Christmas. Plus an assist against Newcastle on Tuesday. We take it all back. Almost.
Broja scores against Bournemouth (Michael Steele/Getty Images)
124. Borna Sosa, Ajax to Crystal Palace
October rating: 125
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £2million
Contract length: Three years
What we said then:Career has flatlined after being earmarked as a future star at Stuttgart. An excellent crosser of the ball, though, so every cloud.
What we’re saying now: He was very cheap, so perhaps not much should have been expected of the Croatia international wing-back. In that, he’s absolutely delivered. A daft red card in the UEFA Conference League and not a lot else.
123. James McAtee, Man City to Forest
October rating: 64
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £30million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Joins Morgan Gibbs-White, Elliot Anderson and Omari Hutchinson as a core of fledgling English talents at Forest. In theory a great addition, but the 22-year-old has only been handed one start in the league, which is typical of Forest’s chaotic start to the season.
What we’re saying now: Given the money involved, the reputation and the ability, a huge flop so far. Just 149 minutes in the Premier League, and reports suggest he could be on the move again in January.
122. Jadon Sancho, Manchester United to Villa
October rating: 153
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:Did anything scream ‘deadline-day panic’ more than Villa getting Sancho through the door on Monday? And they’re paying 80 per cent of his £12million annual salary. Oh, Villa.
What we’re saying now: Flashes of brilliance, particularly in his cameo off the bench against Chelsea last weekend, but an anonymous performance at Arsenal three days later was more reflective of his Villa stint so far.
Sancho played against Arsenal on Tuesday (David Price/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)
121. Benjamin Lecomte, Montpellier to Fulham
October rating: 124
Reported transfer fee: £500,000
Contract length: Two years
What we said then:French goalkeeper who arrives in the Premier League aged 34, and with 329 Ligue 1 appearances to his name, to be Bernd Leno’s backup and, it seems, to play in the cups.
What we’re saying now: Four Carabao Cup appearances for Lecomte, who looked pretty good and won Fulham a penalty shootout against third-tier Wycombe Wanderers. Like many of the No 2 goalkeepers signed by Premier League clubs last summer, he was an obvious upgrade.
120. Jair Cunha, Botafogo to Forest
October rating: 80
Reported transfer fee: £10million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:The 20-year-old centre-back is very much in the up-and-coming mould, with emphasis on the word ‘up’ – he’s 6ft 6in (198cm) and needs climbing up to win headers against, but he still has ‘good feet for a big lad’. Handed his debut against Newcastle and impressed.
What we’re saying now: Not been seen since, with Nikola Milenkovic and Murillo the cemented centre-back pairing.
119. Kepa Arrizabalaga, Chelsea to Arsenal
October rating: 144
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £5million
Contract length: Three years
What we said then:An upgrade on their previous backup goalkeepers Neto and Aaron Ramsdale, albeit he’s unlikely to challenge David Raya too strenuously for the No 1 spot.
What we’re saying now: His season (as well as what seems like much of his English football career) has been dominated by the Carabao Cup, where he was the hero against Crystal Palace in last week’s quarter-final penalty shootout.
Kepa with Gunnersaurus (Alex Burstow/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)
118. Walter Benitez, PSV to Palace
October rating: 121
Transfer fee: Free
Reported contract length: Three years
What we said then:Probably the best backup goalkeeper signing of the summer in the Premier League? You’ll never sing that, etc. Brings nine years of top-level European experience with Nice and PSV.
What we’re saying now: Five appearances (three in the Carabao Cup and two in the UEFA Conference League) which have confirmed his reputation as a very able deputy to Dean Henderson.
117. Arnaud Kalimuendo, Rennes to Forest
October rating: 118
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £26million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:The 23-year-old scored 17 goals in Ligue 1 last season and adds to Forest’s strength in depth. Hasn’t featured much yet, though.
What we’re saying now: And still hasn’t featured much. Well, in the Europa League he’s impressed with two goals in four appearances but in the Premier League he’s only played 80 minutes spread over eight appearances, which has been a source of frustration for some Forest fans.
116. Axel Tuanzebe, Ipswich Town to Burnley
October rating: 116
Transfer fee: Free
Reported contract length: One year
What we said then:Will hope to avoid a second successive relegation from the Premier League. A cheap, versatile squad player.
What we’re saying now: Had a decent run in the side, and is now away at AFCON with DR Congo.
115. Olivier Boscagli, PSV to Brighton
October rating: 113
Transfer fee: Free
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:A pacy, ball-playing defender who completed more long passes than anyone in Europe’s top seven divisions in 2023-24. Could be one of the summer’s best deals if/when he breaks into the team.
What we’re saying now: Just two Premier League starts in what’s been a frustrating beginning to his Brighton career.
114. Facundo Buonanotte, Brighton to Chelsea
October rating: 102
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:One of those deals you see mooted on social media and have to double-check that it’s not from a parody account.
What we’re saying now: Yep, still weird. Hasn’t been seen in the Premier League since September, with most of his minutes coming in the Champions League, a squad he was initially left out of before Essugo’s injury saw him drafted in. A proper classic, old-school mad Chelsea signing.
Buonanotte, proper Chels (Adrian Dennis/AFP via Getty Images)
113. Jackson Tchatchoua, Verona to Wolves
October rating: 99
Reported transfer fee: £10.8million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Replaces outgoing captain Nelson Semedo at right wing-back. That’s a downgrade in theory, but Tchatchoua does offer breathtaking pace; albeit he is very raw.
What we’re saying now: The 23-year-old Cameroon international should have been a 100m sprinter. Does the ball belong at his feet? The jury remains out.
112. Arthur Masuaku, Besiktas to Sunderland
October rating: 101
Transfer fee: Free
Contract length: Two years
What we said then:Former West Ham man Masuaku is expected to deputise for fellow newcomer Reinildo Mandava. A bit of a ‘body through the door’, but a necessary one.
What we’re saying now: A rare thing in that he is a Sunderland signing who hasn’t made an impact, but then it was never really expected he would. Last seen in early October.
111. Christantus Uche, Getafe to Palace
October rating: 130
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:Interesting player with an impressive recent history. Getafe converted Uche from a defensive midfielder into a forward. One of the more intriguing signings of the summer but sadly just seven league minutes off the bench so far.
What we’re saying now: Has suffered from manager Oliver Glasner’s preference for rotating a tight group of players, with only 70 minutes over seven Premier League appearances. Mostly used in the Conference League and is starting to show signs of his ability, albeit he’s not trusted yet.
110. Anthony Elanga, Forest to Newcastle United
October rating: 63
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £55million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:How much?! But, fine, it’s hard to see how this won’t be a good addition given Elanga’s rapid improvement at Forest in the past two years. No goals and one assist in 10 matches, though. It’s been a slow start.
What we’re saying now: Up to two assists now but still no goals from 25 appearances in all competitions. Just not performing at the level he’s capable of.
(Robbie Jay Barratt – AMA/Getty Images)
109. Evann Guessand, Nice to Villa
October rating: 55
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £30.4million (with add-ons)
Reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:Definitely got something about him, but it’s not clear yet what he is in terms of a player profile.
What we’re saying now: Hmmm. No goal contributions in 12 Premier League appearances and, well, there’s not much more to say, really. Has added very little to Villa’s attack.
108. Diego Coppola, Verona to Brighton
October rating: 112
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £9.4million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:A towering aerial presence who broke into the Italy squad last season. Strong, physical, athletic and pretty quick, too, but only 21, so will need time.
What we’re saying now: The youngster was handed recent starts against Sunderland and Arsenal but is behind Lewis Dunk and Jan Paul van Hecke in the pecking order. Will want more game time, particularly if Italy reach the World Cup via the UEFA play-offs in March.
107. David Moller Wolfe, AZ to Wolves
October rating: 111
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £9.9million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Replaces Rayan Ait-Nouri in the team after his move to Manchester City. The 6ft 1in (185cm) Norway left-back has looked out of his depth, though.
What we’re saying now: Improved somewhat in defensive areas but found completely wanting going forward. A limited player, albeit in a horrific Wolves team.
106. Veljko Milosavljevic, Crvena Zvezda to Bournemouth
October rating: 104
Reported transfer fee: £13million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:It’s hard to think of anything more 2025 than Bournemouth having £13m to spend on an 18-year-old centre-back who’s only played 17 top-flight matches in Serbia.
What we’re saying now: Has filled in with the odd appearance and there. One for the future.
105. Mathys Tel, Bayern to Tottenham
October rating: 97
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £38.9million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Six years
What we said then:Huge potential and still very young, having turned 20 in April, but potential is all it is for the moment. Left out of Spurs’ Champions League squad.
What we’re saying now: It felt like his loan from last season’s winter window should have been left as exactly that and Tel hasn’t done much to disprove that theory. Currently behind Wilson Odobert in the pecking order, meaning he’s the backup to a backup. Not great for almost £40m. Squad planning, anyone?
Tel, back-up to the back-up (Julian Finney/Getty Images)
104. Yeremy Pino, Villarreal to Palace
October rating: 38
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: Over £21.6million
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:If someone said four years ago that Pino would end up at Palace, you’d think his career had gone drastically wrong, but this wonderkid at Villarreal saw his progress stalled by a serious knee injury in late 2023. Thrilling to watch at times.
What we’re saying now: Scored an incredible goal at Wolves in November but otherwise he’s flattered to deceive, with some flashes of genius but not a huge amount at the end of it.
103. Habib Diarra, Strasbourg to Sunderland
October rating: 96
Reported transfer fee: £30million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:A dynamic, all-action, box-to-box midfielder who has already greatly elevated Sunderland’s midfield and will look to drive forward and score goals. Very talented, and only 21. Started so well but underwent groin surgery at the end of September.
What we’re saying now: Finally returned on December 20 as a sub against Brighton, and then off he went to AFCON with Senegal. Sunderland will pray he is in one piece when he returns to England after the tournament.
102. Simon Adingra, Brighton to Sunderland
October rating: 94
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £20.7million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Only five assists and 12 goals in 73 appearances for Brighton leave a question mark over his end-product, as does their willingness to let him leave relatively cheaply.
What we’re saying now: Well, you can see why Brighton were happy to let him go. The 23-year-old comes with talent and skill, but not the ability to take control of matches. Not yet, anyway.
101. Christian Norgaard, Brentford to Arsenal
October rating: 89
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £12million (with add-ons)
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Two years
What we said then:A vital cog in Brentford’s wheel but unlikely to have the same impact at a much higher level with Arsenal, particularly given his likely lack of rhythm when he does get a game as a result of being mostly a backup.
What we’re saying now: Very limited involvement, apart from in the Carabao Cup. A pure backup option should an injury crisis occur in midfield.
100. Jorrel Hato, Ajax to Chelsea
October rating: 83
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: Over £34.5million
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Seven years
What we said then:Classic Chelsea stockpiling. Still only a teenager (aged 19), but played 111 times for Ajax and has been in and out of the Netherlands’ senior squad for almost two years. He may have to bide his time behind Marc Cucurella.
What we’re saying now: No Premier League minutes since early October. Very much a bench-warmer for now, and an expensive one at that.
(Michael Steele/Getty Images)
99. Charalampos Kostoulas, Olympiacos to Brighton
October rating: 126
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £31.3million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:There are high expectations for the 6ft 1in (185cm) 18-year-old, who mostly operates as a striker, but he’s largely been kept under wraps for now, with just a couple of brief Carabao Cup sub appearances.
What we’re saying now: Been given time to adapt to England and has looked lively during a series of fleeting, late substitute appearances. Plenty more to come here, you feel.
98. Lukas Nmecha, Wolfsburg to Leeds
October rating: 106
Transfer fee: Free
Contract length: Two years
What we said then:His ability is not in doubt, but the 26-year-old has endured horrendous luck with injuries. A low-risk punt.
What we’re saying now: A ratio of four goals and one injury is a pretty good return so far.
97. Bertrand Traore, Ajax to Sunderland
October rating: 105
Reported transfer fee: Around £2.5million
Contract length: One year
What we said then:The 29-year-old former Chelsea and Villa winger offers Sunderland something slightly different in terms of being a left-footed player who drifts in from the right.
What we’re saying now: A consistent and persistent presence on Sunderland’s right flank, who gives his all before generally being subbed off after an hour.
96. Jacob Ramsey, Villa to Newcastle
October rating: 123
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £44million (with add-ons)
Reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:Very ‘pure profit’, this. Newcastle were short of midfield cover and Ramsey, with his dynamism, athleticism and positive attacking mindset, gives them a fresh option. Injury history is a concern.
What we’re saying now: A few promising moments but also plenty of inconsistency in what’s been a (predictably) injury-affected start to his Newcastle career. Not a bad player at all, but if we’re talking pound-for-pound signings (which we absolutely are) it feels hard to justify that fee right now.
(Robbie Jay Barratt – AMA/Getty Images)
95. Dilane Bakwa, Strasbourg to Forest
October rating: 71
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £30.3million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:The 23-year-old Frenchman produced 12 goals and 21 assists in 71 matches at Strasbourg after moving from Bordeaux in summer 2023. Talented and quick, but a mixed bag so far as he acclimatises to English football.
What we’re saying now: Some initial promise but sidelined for a while with a hamstring injury, before recently making his comeback.
94. Aaron Ramsdale, Southampton to Newcastle
October rating: 122
Transfer fee: Loan (reported £4million to £5m fee)
Contact length: One year
What we said then:Appears to have a genuine redemption story in his grasp at Newcastle, given their current first-choice goalkeeper Nick Pope’s inconsistent form. The epitome of good competition.
What we’re saying now: Played six games in a row in place of Pope and was certainly better than him with his feet, but has kept no clean sheets and wasn’t as commanding of his area. Dropped for the win against Burnley on Tuesday.
93. Nicolo Savona, Juventus to Forest
October rating: 82
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £12million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Lofty (6ft 2in/192cm) Juventus academy graduate who broke into the first team there last year, starting 29 games in all competitions and earning an Italy call-up.
What we’re saying now: You wondered why Juventus were happy to let a young-ish player leave for such a small fee… and it’s since become pretty apparent. When you’ve been labelled as “Carl Jenkinson reincarnated” on social media, it’s safe to say it’s not going well.
92. Rayan Ait-Nouri, Wolves to Man City
October rating: 95
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £31.2million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Came on in leaps and bounds at Wolves and can be spectacular but still needs to refine his defensive game and add finesse in attack.
What we’re saying now: After missing two months with an ankle injury, has only played two minutes in the Premier League since returning in late October, with Nico O’Reilly preferred at left-back and Ait-Nouri sat on the bench, his City career having stalled. Now away at AFCON with Algeria.
91. Jean-Clair Todibo, Nice to West Ham
October rating: 120
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £32.8million
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:France international defender Todibo was considered a real coup when initially signed on loan a year ago, but he blew hot and cold in his debut season. Plenty to prove and dropped by both Graham Potter and now Nuno.
What we’re saying now: Finally on a consistent run of decent form with 12 league appearances in a row, but then picked up an injury that forced him off this week against Brighton. Story of his West Ham career, really.
90. Randal Kolo Muani, Paris Saint-Germain to Tottenham
October rating: 132
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract: One year
What we said then:Bit of a statement signing. So quick, so dangerous in the final third, and surely so motivated to revive his career in a World Cup year. Nicely done.
What we’re saying now: Slow start with an injury, but hasn’t made much of an impact yet. Recently moved out to the left-forward role, where he’s been largely ineffective.
89. Brian Brobbey, Ajax to Sunderland
October rating: 100
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £17million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Three fleeting substitute appearances, with Wilson Isidor’s goals keeping him out of the XI. Made a nuisance of himself at times but nothing substantial of note yet.
What we’re saying now: Produced two of the best moments of Sunderland’s season with his last-gasp equaliser against Arsenal and the winner in the comeback victory over Bournemouth.
Brobbey scores against Arsenal (George Wood/Getty Images)
88. Marco Bizot, Brest to Villa
October rating: 27
Transfer fee: Undisclosed
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Three years
What we said then:Had been Brest’s No 1 goalkeeper for the past four seasons and moved to Villa Park probably expecting to be their Carabao Cup goalkeeper, but will now be known for one of the Premier League’s greatest managerial interview meltdowns… “Marco Bizot.”
What we’re saying now: Eight appearances in total due to various ailments and withdrawals from Emiliano Martinez. Clearly better than the man he replaced as their No 2, Robin Olsen. Can’t say fairer than that.
87. John Victor, Botafogo to Forest
October rating: 137
Transfer fee: Undisclosed
Contract length: Three years
What we said then:Another ceiling botherer at 6ft 5in (197cm). Aged 29, but spent most of his career on the bench before Botafogo gave him his big chance two years ago; however, it’ll be back to a watching brief for now behind Matz Sels.
What we’re saying now: Has overtaken Sels as Forest’s No 1 for the time being. Decent at claiming crosses, is quick at recycling possession and can pull off a decent save. It’ll be interesting to see if he can hold onto the jersey.
86. Douglas Luiz, Juventus to Forest
October rating: 59
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:A player Forest could only dream of signing a couple of years ago. If he shows his old Villa form… sheesh. Still only 27, too.
What we’re saying now: A half-season dominated by injury issues. Hasn’t been able to show anywhere near the level he is capable of.
85. Amine Adli, Bayer Leverkusen to Bournemouth
October rating: 78
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £25.1million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:The 25-year-old Morocco international winger is Dango Outtara’s replacement, and a pretty good one at that.
What we’re saying now: Hmm, just three starts so far and his poor form/lack of minutes meant he wasn’t named in his country’s AFCON squad.
84. Alejandro Garnacho, Man Utd to Chelsea
October rating: 81
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £40million
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Seven years
What we said then:Are Chelsea getting the player who could and should evolve into a global star? Or is this Jadon Sancho 2.0? The jury is out.
What we’re saying now: Just incredibly frustrating. Football’s version of ‘All the gear, but no idea’, Garnacho is ridiculously talented and has a long list of attributes, but his abysmal decision-making tends to override all that.
(Henry Nicholls/AFP via Getty Images)
83. Yoane Wissa, Brentford to Newcastle
October rating: 145
Reported transfer fee: £55million (with add-ons)
Reported contract length: Four years
What we said then:Was Wissa really worth the hassle and the dough? He probably doesn’t even get in Newcastle’s best XI, however he is a good addition to their forward options in a busy European season. Now sidelined with a knee injury.
What we’re saying now: Starting to shoot up this list. Scored in his first Newcastle start, against Fulham in the Carabao Cup, then scored on his full Premier League debut for them at Burnley. A dream start which puts him only one goal behind Alexander Isak’s 2025-26 tally from 580 fewer minutes…
82. Jeremie Frimpong, Leverkusen to Liverpool
October rating: 48
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £29.6million
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:Fast, fast and fast. Frimpong’s pace covers a multitude of defensive sins, and he’s a big asset in attack. Low price and good age (24), but may need to rein in his instincts at times.
What we’re saying now: An extremely frustrating injury-hit start to life at Liverpool. His assist against Wolves at the weekend showed the advantage of his pace against a low block.
81. Jorgen Strand Larsen, Celta Vigo to Wolves
October rating: 47
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £23million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:The fact Newcastle were considering a bid of around £60m for a player who had cost Wolves £23m (turning a summer 2024 loan permanent) two months earlier backs up the theory that this was one of the best-value deals of the summer.
What we’re saying now: Wolves should have cashed in. They’d now be lucky to get 60 million old Italian Lira for a player who is completely devoid of confidence (and service, to be fair) and has been booed by his own fans. And dropped. Oh, Wolves. It was a bargain deal at the time and given his past exploits, they should still get a decent fee for the Norwegian when he inevitably moves on.
80. Liam Delap, Ipswich to Chelsea
October rating: 109
Transfer fee: £30million
Contract length: Six years
What we said then:It’s a big step up in level, but the 22-year-old appears to have the attributes and attitude to make it. Just a shame he’s pinged his hamstring for the time being.
What we’re saying now: Returned from that injury only to immediately get a daft red card at Wolves in the Carabao Cup, then was out again with a shoulder problem. Yet to score for Chelsea in the Premier League, and yet to find his feet there.
(Nathan Stirk/Getty Images)
79. Djordje Petrovic, Chelsea to Bournemouth
October rating: 37
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £25million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Yep, very good. Solid start with three clean sheets so far, aiding Bournemouth’s title bid.
What we’re saying now: Like Bournemouth, started so well, but like Bournemouth, it ain’t looking great right now. Has the worst post-shot expected goals (xG) figure of any regular starting keeper in the division with -3.9. Could do with some senior competition as a backup option.
78. Jacob Bruun Larsen, Stuttgart to Burnley
October rating: 76
Reported transfer fee: £3million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then: Jacob Bruun Larsen is back, everybody! Remember? A cheap, utility, attacking squad player. In and out of the side, workmanlike displays, what you see is what you get.
What we’re saying now: Epitomises Burnley in that he works hard enough and doesn’t lack desire or character… but the top-level quality just isn’t there.
77. Jaidon Anthony, Bournemouth to Burnley
October rating: 12
Reported transfer fee: £8million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:A wonderful start to the season with four goals in seven Premier League appearances. Absolutely flying and making a mockery of that £8m fee.
What we’re saying now: No goals since September and, if truth be told, not a lot else to write home about. If he’s not scoring, Anthony isn’t offering much.
76. Bafode Diakite, Lille to Bournemouth
October rating: 29
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £34.6million (with add-ons)
Reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:Aggressive, technical French centre-back who was a pillar of Lille’s defence last season, including in the Champions League. Aged 24 and looks capable of big things.
What we’re saying now: After quickly settling into life in the Premier League, the aggressive Diakite’s form has tailed off and he was dropped for Bournemouth’s most recent match, away to Chelsea.
75. Tolu Arokodare, Genk to Wolves
October rating: 88
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £23.4million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:The Belgian league’s Golden Boot winner (don’t be too impressed by that, seeing as Deniz Undav and Paul Onuachu are two of his predecessors) is, aged 24 and at 6ft 5in (197cm), a likely backup for Jorgen Strand Larsen.
What we’re saying now: Wolves’ top scorer in all competitions with (don’t laugh) three goals. Scored against leaders Arsenal at the Emirates and has dislodged Strand Larsen up front due to offering a more physical threat. Getting better.
74. Quilindschy Hartman, Feyenoord to Burnley
October rating: 60
Reported transfer fee: £10million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Feels like a real coup for Burnley to sign the 23-year-old Netherlands international left-back, who is eyeing a World Cup spot next summer.
What we’re saying now: Started so well, including an exceptional performance against Liverpool and Mohamed Salah, but tailed off badly, culminating in a dreadful performance against Fulham in mid-December. Was subsequently dropped and is now out of the matchday squad amid suggestions of a January bid from Ajax.
73. Benjamin Sesko, RB Leipzig to Man Utd
October rating: 32
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £73.6million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:The 22-year-old is not the finished product but United are getting a lightning-quick, relentless, agile attacking artist who, in theory, should be a superstar in time.
What we’re saying now: It’s safe to say United haven’t seen anywhere near the best of Sesko yet, mostly due to injuries. Patience will be in short supply, given the fee and the club, but he needs time to prove himself.
(Mike Hewitt/Getty Images)
72. Callum Wilson, Newcastle to West Ham
October rating: 91
Transfer fee: Free
Contract length: One year
What we said then:Are West Ham getting the England international of only two years ago, or the guy who didn’t score last season in 22 short-lived appearances (spread across just 458 minutes) and is now 33?
What we’re saying now: A record of 0.5 goals per 90 minutes places him in the top 10 prolific scorers in the 2025-26 Premier League, but Nuno has mostly played Wilson off the bench, preferring to start matches with players who aren’t strikers up front instead. Never a good sign.
71. Carlos Alcaraz, Flamengo to Everton
October rating: 53
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £12.6million
Contract length: Two years
What we said then:Certainly did enough on loan at Everton in the second half of last season to suggest that £12.6m is a bargain fee for the 22-year-old Argentinian attacking midfielder.
What we’re saying now: Had to wait for injuries and suspensions to get his opportunities, and hasn’t really taken them. Often too hesitant in possession, with a poor final pass.
70. Alexander Isak, Newcastle to Liverpool
October rating: 87
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £125million
Reported contract length: Six years
What we said then:Isak could very well become the best striker in the world now he’s at Anfield. With no pre-season to speak of, it’s only now that he is getting up to speed, fitness-wise. Impossible to judge him properly before then.
What we’re saying now: Is out for several months with a fractured ankle after an unconvincing period of three goals in 781 minutes of football. Was constantly playing catch-up after missing pre-season which was, of course, entirely of his own making.
69. Jamie Gittens, Borussia Dortmund to Chelsea
October rating: 86
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £52million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Seven years
What we said then:Gittens is hugely talented, but not the finished product, and it’s difficult to envisage him becoming that at a club like Chelsea.
What we’re saying now: The 21-year-old needs regular starts and plenty of minutes to grow and mature as a player but he’s not really getting those at Chelsea, as expected. One goal in 20 convoluted appearances, and it was in the Carabao Cup.
68. Jaydee Canvot, Toulouse to Palace
October rating: 92
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £22.9million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Marc Guehi’s long-term successor? Turned 19 just over a month ago and has only 14 Ligue 1 starts to his name. Quick, athletic and can operate at defensive midfield, too.
What we’re saying now: A horrible mistake cost Palace October’s match against Larnaca in the Conference League, but he was exceptional in the heat of a rivalry game against Brighton in the Premier League a couple of weeks later. Twelve appearances so far in what will be a year of learning before he likely steps into Guehi’s boots next season.
67. Lucas Perri, Lyon to Leeds
October rating: 85
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £15.6million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Another doorway-frame ducker for Leeds, this 6ft 5in (197cm) Brazilian goalkeeper feels like an upgrade on Illan Meslier after a decent 2024-25 season in Ligue 1, but only time will tell.
What we’re saying now: Can be slow off his line but, after a mixed start which included a spell out injured, Perri’s improved form has coincided with that of his team.
66. Kyle Walker-Peters, Southampton to West Ham
October rating: 84
Transfer fee: Free
Contract length: Three years
What we said then:The 28-year-old’s versatility should be helpful. Surprisingly usurped last year’s player of the season Aaron Wan-Bissaka at right-back.
What we’re saying now: Has mostly been Wan-Bissaka’s back-up since then, but now back in the side with his colleague away at AFCON with DR Congo.
65. Tyler Dibling, Southampton to Everton
October rating: 54
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £40million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:A ball-carrying magician. Elegance personified in the way he saunters upfield and past defenders, although he is only 19 and his all-round game (including his end-product) needs a lot of work.
What we’re saying now: Mostly late cameo appearances from the bench so far as he learns his trade under Moyes.
(James Gill – Danehouse/Getty Images)
64. Viktor Gyokeres, Sporting CP to Arsenal
October rating: 31
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £63.4million (with adds-ons)
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:Three goals in 10 appearances represents a fair return, but it’ll be time to kick on soon if he really is to be that game-changer for Arsenal’s title prospects this season. Great at charging after loose balls, less so at controlling said ball.
What we’re saying now: Has not kicked-on since then, with only two more league goals (against Burnley and Everton). Helps create space for others, but isn’t yet the penalty-box presence Arsenal need him to be.
63. Dango Ouattara, Bournemouth to Brentford
October rating: 77
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £42million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Was too inconsistent for Iraola’s liking, only averaging a goal or assist every 175 minutes in all competitions last season. His talent isn’t in doubt, but it is an astonishing amount of money either way.
What we’re saying now: A burst of two goals and four assists in a five-match run in the autumn remains the highlight of an inconsistent but improving spell at Brentford so far.
62. Florentino Luis, Benfica to Burnley
October rating: 67
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:Only one Primeira Liga midfielder produced more tackles and interceptions combined than his 134 last season. A defensive midfielder’s defensive midfielder.
What we’re saying now: Yep, those tackle stats are still decent (fifth in the league for tackles won with 31) and has done pretty well in a struggling side.
61. Noni Madueke, Chelsea to Arsenal
October rating: 61
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £52million (with add-ons)
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:Positives: a very effective, direct and pacy dribbler who excels in one-v-one situations. Negatives: can be injury-prone, can be inconsistent, his end-product needs work, and the fee is very large for a likely backup forward.
What we’re saying now: Pretty much exactly as expected. He’s contributed well when fit, but is no Bukayo Saka. Epitomises Arsenal’s squad-building approach of last summer, which is paying off handsomely.
(Stuart MacFarlane/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)
60. Matheus Cunha, Wolves to Man Utd
October rating: 73
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £62.5million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:A truly gifted footballer who has already proved he can thrive in the Premier League, but ironing out the temperament issues that scared higher-ranked teams off will be key. It’s taking him time to get used to not being the team’s main man, like he was at Wolves.
What we’re saying now: With Sesko suffering with form and fitness, Bryan Mbeumo off at AFCON with Cameroon and Bruno Fernandes injured, United could really do with Cunha stepping up to be that main man, but it just hasn’t happened yet. Three goals and one assist so far, despite only Erling Haaland of Manchester City having more shots than his 40 so far. He mostly tries to do too much and ends up doing nothing. But the talent is undeniable.
59. Milos Kerkez, Bournemouth to Liverpool
October rating: 68
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: Around £40million
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:May take a while to settle in and adapt, but it’s hard to see the 21-year-old Hungarian, who was recently named in the PFA Premier League Team of the Year for last season, not being a success.
What we’re saying now: Put in some lamentable early performances and was briefly dropped. Some encouraging signs more recently, although his runs down the left continue to often be ignored.
58. Dan Ndoye, Bologna to Forest
October rating: 44
Reported transfer fee: £35million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:The 24-year-old Switzerland international isn’t the finished product, and his lack of physicality may be an issue, but his desire to take players on and make things happen will be fun to watch.
What we’re saying now: A goal and an assist in his first two Premier League appearances, but has produced nothing since. Recently dropped out of the team.
57. Kevin Danso, Lens to Tottenham
October rating: 110
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £20.9million
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:Given the injury records of Cristian Romero and Micky van de Ven, he’ll play plenty. Limited as a player but very solid and a great character in the dressing room.
What we’re saying now: A substantial 18 appearances in all competitions and he’s mostly done a great job when called upon, particularly if that job is to head crosses clear.
56. Piero Hincapie, Leverkusen to Arsenal
October rating: 107
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:Hincapie has been primed for a move to an elite European club for some time; the 23-year-old can play at left centre-back or as a wing-back but picked up a groin injury on his Arsenal debut and hasn’t been seen since.
What we’re saying now: Versatility has proved to be a real strength, filling in at both centre-back and left-back. Fully committed in everything he does.
(Julian Finney/Getty Images)
55. Zian Flemming, Millwall to Burnley
October rating: 115
Reported transfer fee: £7million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Has a name that suggests he arrived from a tropical location. Nope, just Bermondsey. Solid Championship performer. Should chip in here and there.
What we’re saying now: Five goals in 15 Premier League appearances and is only behind Haaland and Liverpool’s Hugo Ekitike for goals scored per 90 minutes, with a rate of 0.67. And yet most weeks, he can’t even get in the starting line-up. Burnley must have a hell of a side.
54. Chemsdine Talbi, Club Brugge to Sunderland
October rating: 49
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: Around £19.5million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:A highly rated 20-year-old Belgium youth international whose addition is a bit of a coup. High ceiling, but he’s only 5ft 9in (175cm), so that’s not an issue. Been a little isolated at times, but clearly talented and looks like there’s plenty more to come.
What we’re saying now: Mostly used from the bench but has shown his undoubted class and chipped in with memorable goals against Chelsea and Liverpool. Another classic Sunderland signing who will probably only get better.
53. Lutsharel Geertruida, Leipzig to Sunderland
October rating: 66
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:The 25-year-old Netherlands international joined Leipzig for around £17m last summer after coming through the ranks at Feyenoord. He played more than 200 times for the Rotterdam club, mostly at right-back, but he can also fit in as a central defender.
What we’re saying now: His versatility has proved very useful with appearances at centre-back, right-back and also in midfield. A classy player who progresses the ball nicely.
52. Kevin, Shakhtar Donetsk to Fulham
October rating: 42
Reported transfer fee: £34.6m
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:An exciting 22-year-old Brazilian left-winger who evolved into the star of Shakhtar’s attack last season. Stepovers, skills, invention, pace, two good feet and a lot of fun.
What we’re saying now: The talent is there but the consistency is not and after a bright start, he has tailed off. Just one assist and no goals in the league so far. A long-term purchase, though, and there is so much to work with.
51. Xavi Simons, Leipzig to Tottenham
October rating: 46
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £52million
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:Tough to judge, this one, but he could be a game-changer for Spurs if Thomas Frank can mould the attack around him.
What we’re saying now: Great goal against Brentford, yes; daft red card against Liverpool, no. A real mixed bag and an enigmatic presence who sums up Tottenham’s season in that he should be so much better than he is.
(Alex Pantling/Getty Images)
50. Jaka Bijol, Udinese to Leeds
October rating: 119
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £15million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Slovenia international centre-back. The 6ft 3in (190cm) 26-year-old’s profile was summed up by an Athletic subscriber under a recent Leeds article: “Big, hard b*****d that can play a bit. Nice one.”
What we’re saying now: Came into the side in October and has played an understated role in Leeds’ excellent recent form.
49. Victor Lindelof, Man Utd to Villa
October rating: 131
Transfer fee: Free
Contract length: Two years
What we said then:Hard to pick fault with this one, given Villa’s financial restrictions. Remains fourth-choice centre-back.
What we’re saying now: A bit of a revelation, having come into the side in early December due to Pau Torres’ injury. The Swede has been a class act, with an excellent passing range. Excellent addition and saved the club a few quid. Villa’s signing of the summer, but that’s like Justin Timberlake winning, ‘Best NSYNC Member’.
48. Samuel Chukwueze, Milan to Fulham
October rating: 75
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:The 26-year-old right-winger is a wait-and-see addition but his quality has been obvious, even from substitute cameos.
What we’re saying now: A slow start, then a brilliant burst of two goals (both against Manchester City) and three assists in five games… but now at AFCON with Nigeria. Looking like a really good addition, albeit only on loan. Fulham will want him back safely soon.
47. Soungoutou Magassa, Monaco to West Ham
October rating: 62
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: Around £17.3million
Reported contract length: Four years
What we said then:French defensive midfielder who started to make a big impact with Monaco last season. He was in the top five players in Ligue 1 for tackles and interceptions combined (5.96 per match) and while he’s only 21, West Ham have bought a player for now as well as the future.
What we’re saying now: Boundless energy, has quality on the ball and isn’t bad going forward. Inconsistent, which is no surprise given his age, but West Ham have themselves a player here.
46. Thierno Barry, Villarreal to Everton
October rating: 56
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £27.5million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:A colossus at 6ft 4in (195cm) who can hold the ball up and is mobile, strong and shows good movement. A bit of a risky one, as yes, he’s raw, and no, he may not score a load of goals just yet.
What we’re saying now: Took until his 16th Everton appearance to produce his first shot on target for the club, against Bournemouth in December. The 22-year-old turns into the original Ronaldo when he plays against Nottingham Forest, with a goal in both matches against Sean Dyche’s lads. Can he play them every week?
45. Cristhian Mosquera, Valencia to Arsenal
October rating: 18
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £13million
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:Forget the future, Mosquera looks ready now. Only 21 but is imposing, strong, calm and good in duels. Looks to be one of the bargains of the summer.
What we’re saying now: Exceptional against Bayern in November and remains a terrific prospect. Sidelined for the time being with an ankle injury and, barring similar lay-offs for team-mates, may not feature too much on this season’s run-in.
44. Noah Sadiki, Union Saint-Gilloise to Sunderland
October rating: 52
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £17.8million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:DR Congo international who fits the Sunderland model in terms of age (20) and experience (134 senior appearances for club and country already). Has done exactly what it says on the tin.
What we’re saying now: One of the hardest-working midfielders in the Premier League, whose unselfishness also helps unlock doors for team-mate Granit Xhaka to open.
43. Enzo Le Fee, Roma to Sunderland
October rating: 51
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £20million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Ridiculously talented, works his a**e off and has the touch of an angel. There is a question mark over exactly where head coach Regis Le Bris fits him into the Sunderland XI.
What we’re saying now: A decent haul of three assists but most importantly, his work rate makes him a vital cog in the Sunderland machine, whether he plays on the left or more centrally.
42. Giorgi Mamardashvili, Valencia to Liverpool
October rating: 50
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £29million (with add-ons)
Reported contract length: Six years
What we said then:You’d be hard-pressed to find a better shot-stopping goalkeeper in his age range in Europe than the giant (6ft 5in/197cm) 24-year-old Georgia international.
What we’re saying now: Has played 10 times already, owing to deputising for the injured Alisson. Lacked the assuredness of the more experienced Brazilian but produced some outstanding saves.
41. Lesley Ugochukwu, Chelsea to Burnley
October rating: 45
Reported transfer fee: Over £20million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:That’s big money for Burnley. The 21-year-old France youth international didn’t enjoy his time at Southampton (on loan from Chelsea last season) but is a massive presence in Burnley’s midfield.
What we’re saying now: Competitive, aggressive and showing signs he could thrive in the Premier League, certainly if given a chance in a better team than this one. Positionally, he can be frustrating. Has chipped in with three goals.
40. Noah Okafor, Milan to Leeds
October rating: 43
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £18million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Leeds have loved a gamble on an injury-prone attacker this summer. Already in the team and making an impact.
What we’re saying now: Works hard, loves to take a player on, although the end-product isn’t quite there yet. A decent foil for Dominic Calvert-Lewin in recent weeks.
39. Omari Hutchinson, Ipswich to Nottingham Forest
October rating: 69
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £37.5million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Forest are paying a premium because of his nationality (English) and his potential (high). One of those who you’d expect more from in a better team, but has bizarrely been left out of their Europa League squad.
What we’re saying now: Despite being used as a pawn in that particular tug-of-war while Nuno was still Forest’s head coach, Hutchinson has quietly got on with his business. Had a run of four assists in four games at one point and scored his first goal against Manchester City last week. It feels like he’s kicking on now.
(Alex Pantling/Getty Images)
38. Sean Longstaff, Newcastle to Leeds
October rating: 5
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £15million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Has brought stability and dynamism in midfield, also offers good set-piece deliveries and suits Leeds’ physical approach. The second-best tackler in the Premier League so far too with 15 won (one behind Tyrick Mitchell of Palace). Very good.
What we’re saying now: That early form levelled out a little bit, and he’s been out injured since November.
37. El Hadji Malick Diouf, Slavia Prague to West Ham
October rating: 24
Reported transfer fee: £19million
Reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:The Senegal international, one of the outstanding players in the Czech league last season, looks a real prospect. An overlapping full-back who can whip over a hell of a cross.
What we’re saying now: Tailed off a little bit after an enterprising start but he’s only 21 and, with his effectiveness going forward, has attributes to thrive in the Premier League for years to come.
36. Reinildo Mandava, Atletico Madrid to Sunderland
October rating: 41
Transfer fee: Free
Contract length: Two years
What we said then:The first player from Mozambique in the Premier League (finally!), the 31-year-old has filled Sunderland’s problem left-back position for no fee. At times a class act, although at others overly aggressive.
What we’re saying now: One of the hardest full-backs to beat in the league this season. Solid and consistent.
35. Caoimhin Kelleher, Liverpool to Brentford
October rating: 40
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £18million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:A goalkeeper once described by Jurgen Klopp as the best No 2 in the world now steps up to be a Premier League No 1. Boobed against Manchester United when tickling a cross, then saved a penalty in the same game, but it’s not quite been the assured start Kelleher would have hoped for.
What we’re saying now: Has improved as the season has gone on. Loves a penalty save and is justifying his No 1 status.
34. Senne Lammens, Royal Antwerp to Man Utd
October rating: 57
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £21.7million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:The 23-year-old Belgian was among Europe’s best shot-stopping goalkeepers last season. If The Athletic_’s eight-year-old nephew’s opinion is anything to go by, he’s excellent: “Bro, the guy is a Courtois regen.”_
What we’re saying now: It speaks volumes about Lammens’ performances that, for the first time in a good while, nobody is really talking about United’s goalkeeper.
(Jan Kruger/Getty Images)
33. Maxim De Cuyper, Club Brugge to Brighton
October rating: 39
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £17.3million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Replaces Pervis Estupinan in the squad and provides competition for Ferdi Kadioglu.
What we’re saying now: Lived up to his reputation in that he’s good going forward but not so sharp defensively, something Saka enjoyed taking advantage of when Brighton lost away to Arsenal last week. Has sometimes been moved further up the left wing as a result, but in general, the 25-year-old is a busy, creative addition to Brighton’s squad.
32. Gabriel Gudmundsson, Lille to Leeds
October rating: 20
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £10million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Good for Lille, good for Sweden’s national team, but will the 26-year-old left-back cut it in the Premier League? So far, he looks tenacious, fearless, tidy, good on the ball and defensively tight for the most part.
What we’re saying now: A tireless presence on the left wing who has exceeded expectations and, like a few of his team-mates at Elland Road, made a mockery of his fee.
31. Joao Palhinha, Bayern to Tottenham
October rating: 16
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:For Spurs to bring the former Fulham man back to England for peanuts adds a layer of steel to their midfield that has been missing for some time. In a bit of a culture war at Tottenham in that his presence as a second defensive midfielder is indicative of head coach Frank’s pragmatic approach in home games.
What we’re saying now: Lost that particular culture war to Rodrigo Bentancur, who is the regular in midfield, with Archie Gray now alongside him. Despite that, Palinha has still won more tackles (40) this season than any other Premier League player. Remains the best hairy-a***d tackler in English football.
30. Joao Pedro, Brighton to Chelsea
October rating: 34
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: Over £50million
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Seven years
What we said then:Chelsea’s only quandary is how best to use him in their forward line. Petulant and quite annoying, but also great to watch.
What we’re saying now: Six goals so far represent a decent return but, like Chelsea, he remains a little too inconsistent.
29. Ladislav Krejci, Girona to Wolves
October rating: 15
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: Loan (£6million fee)
Contract length: One year
What we said then:Ball-playing centre-back who can also operate in midfield. The 26-year-old, left-footed Czech Republic international oozes quality and is composure personified. Wolves’ best signing. Shame they didn’t bother with many more.
What we’re saying now: One of very few positives in the worst first half to a Premier League season imaginable. Wolves unearthed a gem when they signed Krejci, who will likely flourish when he is in a better team. The £20m deal already in place to sign him permanently is a bargain.
28. Alex Jimenez, Milan to Bournemouth
October rating: 65
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:Real Madrid and now Milan have both been happy to let the fiery (12 bookings and a red card across all competitions last season) 20-year-old Spain youth international move on. Enter, well… Bournemouth.
What we’re saying now: After Antoine Semenyo, probably Bournemouth’s best player this season? Even during their horrible recent form, he has remained consistently excellent. Very good defensively (he more than held his own against Chelsea’s Estevao the other night) and has all the traits a modern full-back needs. Only 20 years old, too.
27. Eberechi Eze, Palace to Arsenal
October rating: 21
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £67.5million (with add-ons)
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Four years
What we said then:Adds much-needed balance to Arsenal’s attack. Been on the periphery a little bit. Has had the most shots in the Premier League without scoring so far, which he’ll want to end soon.
What we’re saying now: Ended that drought in style with a predictable goal against his former club and then an unforgettable hat-trick in the north London derby. Has barely featured in recent weeks, though. Manager Mikel Arteta knows what he’s getting with Mikel Merino, less so with Eze.
(Catherine Ivill – AMA/Getty Images)
26. Mateus Fernandes, Southampton to West Ham
October rating: 36
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £41million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:The 21-year-old Portuguese is a positive, gifted presence in West Ham’s midfield. Should get better under Nuno.
What we’re saying now: Tackles, duels, recoveries… Fernandes is all-action and has been one of West Ham’s better performers this season. The fee was lofty, but he’s justifying it.
25. Igor Jesus, Botafogo to Forest
October rating: 35
Reported transfer fee: £10million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Has a name that sounds like a Juventus fan lamenting a substitution their manager has made. Forest needed competition for Chris Wood up front, and the 24-year-old fits the bill as a senior Brazil international who has scored at a healthy rate back home.
What we’re saying now: Seven goals in 23 appearances in all competitions (although only one in the Premier League) and overall he’s been an excellent addition, especially at that price.
24. Florian Wirtz, Leverkusen to Liverpool
October rating: 72
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £116million (with add-ons)
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:The key to unlocking defences and arguably the key to Liverpool’s season. The fee is absolutely astronomical. Can he possibly live up to that and the hype?
What we’re saying now: Has often looked on a different wavelength to his new team-mates, which isn’t necessarily a criticism, but creates an impression that Wirtz hasn’t made an impact, whereas in reality, he is sixth in the Premier League for chance creation from open play (with 27). One of the most watchable players in the division (which you’d expect for that fee) and getting better every week.
23. Bryan Mbeumo, Brentford to Man Utd
October rating: 30
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £71million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Busy on and off the ball; works tremendously hard and the end-product will probably come once he hones his role in the side.
What we’re saying now: Six goals in 16 league appearances is a good return for United’s best signing of 2025 by some distance.
22. Kyle Walker, Man City to Burnley
October rating: 19
Reported transfer fee: £5million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Two years
What we said then:A player full of experience in a squad lacking it. Great addition. Tenacious, combative and fully committed to the Burnley cause.
What we’re saying now: The 35-year-old hasn’t exactly had great support around him but has stuck doggedly to his task week after week.
21. Tijjani Reijnders, Milan to Man City
October rating: 25
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £61million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Adds physicality and dynamism to a midfield that sorely lacked it last season. A gliding, elegant midfielder.
What we’re saying now: His impact lessened a bit as he got to grips with the Premier League, but Reijnders’ influence has probably been underrated. Four goals too.
20. Nick Woltemade, Stuttgart to Newcastle
October rating: 7
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £69.3million (with add-ons)
Reported contract length: Six years
What we said then:They can’t exactly call him their first choice, but Newcastle finally have a forward in the door and yes, he’s a very good one. Surname will be pronounced ‘Walt Made’ by thousands of Geordies. Scorer of one of the greatest penalty kicks in Premier League history. A unique talent.
What we’re saying now: Anonymous in some games but spellbinding in others. Nine goals in all competitions is a decent return in an inconsistent side.
(George Wood/Getty Images)
19. Nordi Mukiele, PSG to Sunderland
October rating: 22
Reported transfer fee: £12million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Has played most of his career on the right flank but Le Bris has played Mukiele at centre-back and been rewarded with a couple of colossal performances.
What we’re saying now: Centre-half, right-back, it doesn’t seem to matter where Mukiele plays, his pace, athleticism and composure have led to him becoming a real fans’ favourite on Wearside. Has embraced the club’s culture. Takes great pleasure in winning his individual battles.
18. Omar Alderete, Getafe to Sunderland
October rating: 14
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £11.4million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:Several commanding, unflustered displays and a winning goal against Forest in September. A proper defender.
What we’re saying now: One of the highest-rating centre-backs in the league so far this season. Consistently excellent.
17. Mohammed Kudus, West Ham to Tottenham
October rating: 4
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £55million
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Six years
What we said then:On his day, a maverick with the dribbling ability to light up and win any match, but inconsistency and his temperament have been issues. A change of scenery appears to have done him good.
What we’re saying now: Has produced a whopping 120 crosses, joint-first in the league and 15 more than anyone else. Joint-first with who? New team-mate Pedro Porro. Note, Spurs love crosses. Kudus also loves taking players on, with 50 successful take-ons the most in the league, even more than Manchester City winger Jeremy Doku.
16. Martin Zubimendi, Real Sociedad to Arsenal
October rating: 23
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £55.8million
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Five years
What we said then:If Arsenal get the player they think they are getting, Zubimendi will help facilitate an improved attacking dynamic for Arteta’s side.
What we’re saying now: Has he been the difference-maker for Arsenal this season? Made a solid start and has become more influential, arguably improving Declan Rice’s game while also helping protect the back line. A clear upgrade from Thomas Partey.
15. Jack Grealish, Man City to Everton
October rating: 1
Transfer fee: Loan
Contract length: One year
What we said then:If Grealish, in a World Cup season, is given the freedom to express himself and be their main man, this has a good chance of being one of those ‘benefits everyone’ signings.
What we’re saying now: Was top of our list in early October but the initial burst of four assists that put him there subsided (none since then) and just the two goals so far. His influence remains strong, though. Has produced 78 progressive carries, the third most in the league, and only City colleague Doku has created more chances from open play than his 31.
(Simon Stacpoole/Offside/Offside via Getty Images)
14. Jordan Henderson, Ajax to Brentford
October rating: 26
Transfer fee: Free
Contract length: Two years
What we said then:Slotted back into the Premier League like he hadn’t been away. A couple of man-of-the-match performances and two exceptional long-pass assists against Chelsea and Manchester United.
What we’re saying now: Continued his excellent form as the heartbeat of Brentford’s midfield. Doesn’t just sit and screen… Henderson, despite being 35 years old, still breaks through the lines and links well with the attack. Proved a lot of people wrong this season. And he cost them nothing. What a signing.
13. Adrien Truffert, Rennes to Bournemouth
October rating: 3
Reported transfer fee: £14.4million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Capable of eye-catching and all-encompassing displays on the left wing (both defensively and offensively). Made a flying start, dynamic going forward, and exceptional in August’s win away to Spurs. Excellent signing.
What we’re saying now: Makes overlapping and underlapping runs for fun and is technically gifted. Not quite kept his levels from those early weeks up, but it’s been an excellent first half of the season.
12. Martin Dubravka, Newcastle to Burnley
October rating: 33
Transfer fee: Undisclosed
Contract length: One year
What we said then:As far as cheap goalkeepers go, the 36-year-old Slovakia international is pretty much as good as it gets for a relegation-battling Premier League club. Has commanded his area well, done nothing daft in possession and made a string of good saves (in fact, he has the most saves in the league this season, with 28). A very shrewd signing.
What we’re saying now: Yep, exactly as above. Possibly Burnley’s best player this season. Nobody in the division has made more than his 63 saves, but that’s as much to do with the rabble in front of him as his own goalkeeping prowess.
11. Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, Chelsea to Everton
October rating: 13
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £25million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Creates chances, is incessantly positive and one of the best passers in the league in the final third. Excellent.
What we’re saying now: Since his electric start, he has reined in the bookings (none in nine matches after four in six at one point) and added goals (three in four appearances in November/December). Undoubtedly one of the signings of the summer. Outside chance for England’s World Cup squad?
10. Gianluigi Donnarumma, PSG to Man City
October rating: 8
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £25.9million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:A box-office, Harlem Globetrotter of a goalkeeper, Donnarumma comes with baggage but remains one of the best at his position in the world game.
What we’re saying now: Solid, safe, consistent, agile and a huge personality, Donnarumma’s transfer fee looks pretty cheap for what City have got in return.
(Visionhaus/Getty Images)
9. Anton Stach, Hoffenheim to Leeds
October rating: 28
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: Over £17.3million
Contract length: Four years
What we said then:The 6ft 4in (193cm) midfielder excels at breaking up play, reading and dictating the game and playing incisive passes. A real steal at £17.3m, too.
What we’re saying now: Has lived up to the hype. Good set pieces and a robust, dynamic presence in midfield whose work rate and intelligence make him one of Leeds’ standout performers. Wins more aerial duels (71 per cent) than almost anyone in the league and only four players have produced more than his nine goal-creating actions. A bargain at that fee and, boy, can he strike a football.
8. Malick Thiaw, Milan to Newcastle
October rating: 10
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £34.6million (with add-ons)
Reported contract length: Four years
What we said then:Thiaw, aged 24 and capped three times by Germany, is comfortable on the ball, can play in a high line and is good at switching play. Rolls Royce-type, very calm under pressure, good technique, quick and decent in the air. Could form a solid central defensive partnership with Sven Botman.
What we’re saying now: Has largely continued his exceptional early form. Newcastle’s best signing of the summer and becoming one of the best centre-backs in the Premier League.
7. Robin Roefs, NEC Nijmegen to Sunderland
October rating: 9
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £11.7million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:A bit of a revelation. Good handling, quick off his line and a great shot-stopper. Three clean sheets.
What we’re saying now: Six clean sheets and the second-best post-shot expected goals (xG) tally in the league behind Bart Verbruggen of Brighton. Good character, a big presence, and a substantial reason for Sunderland’s success so far.
6. Estevao, Palmeiras to Chelsea
October rating: 2
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £49million (with add-ons)
Reported contract length: Eight years
What we said then:Arrived against Liverpool, scoring a dramatic late winner. Top of the Premier League list for expected assists per 90 minutes (0.42), eighth for expected goals per 90 (0.54) and eighth for successful take-ons (11). But forget the numbers, just watch him and smile. What a talent.
What we’re saying now: November’s wondergoal against Barcelona will live long in the memory. Head coach Enzo Maresca has used him sparingly in the Premier League as the teenager adapts to English football, but there is no denying what a special player he is.
5. Dominic Calvert-Lewin, Everton to Leeds
October rating: 103
Transfer fee: Free
Contact length: Three years
What we said then:Four successive starts and a nicely-taken goal against Wolves have set a good foundation from which to kick on, injuries permitting, as Calvert-Lewin looks to get back to his best.
What we’re saying now: Six goals, seven games and the eighth wonder of the world in the eyes of Leeds fans after becoming their first player to score in six consecutive matches for 65 years. His goal against Manchester City in late November sparked the fightback during which Leeds are yet to stop punching. One of the feel-good stories of the Premier League season and, well, you never know what might happen come the World Cup. Proving a lot of doubters wrong, anyway.
4. Hugo Ekitike, Eintracht Frankfurt to Liverpool
October rating: 6
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £79million (with add-ons)
The Athletic’s reported contract length: Six years
What we said then:It feels rare for a striker who is both young and extremely expensive to hit the ground running in this way. Ekitike’s pace, height and physicality look ideally suited to the Premier League.
What we’re saying now: Has scored 11 goals in 25 games in all competitions, making him by far the most effective of Liverpool’s summer signings and only behind Haaland for goals per minutes played. Ekitike is clinical and works hard, two vital components for any successful striker. He’s won the selection battle with Isak for now.
3. Michael Kayode, Fiorentina to Brentford
October rating: 17
Reported transfer fee: £14.5million
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:Long throws are in vogue, and this guy is the best in the league at them, with his flat, hard cannonballs. Kayode is also quick and effective going forward when the ball is at his feet, with 12 successful take-ons so far (sixth in the Premier League). Huge potential.
What we’re saying now: Yep, exceptional. Taken 34 more throw-ins than anyone in the division, but his game is about so much more than that particular set piece; has produced the most dribbles by a defender, is great on defensive duels and loves randomly ambling forward at all angles to cause carnage in the opposition third. Only 21, and undoubtedly one of the bargains of the season.
2. Granit Xhaka, Leverkusen to Sunderland
October rating: 11
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £17.3million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Three years
What we said then:Xhaka adds leadership to a young team and, at 32, still has the legs, skill and vision to make a big impact in midfield. Composure personified.
What we’re saying now: Experience and leadership personified. Just epitomises everything great about Sunderland this season, with his quality on the ball underpinned by an incessant desire to fight for the cause in defence and attack. Five assists (only Fernandes of United and City’s Rayan Cherki have more) and acts like a manager on the pitch. Exceptional.
1. Rayan Cherki, Lyon to Man City
October rating: 79
The Athletic’s reported transfer fee: £36.3million (with add-ons)
Contract length: Five years
What we said then:He’s 22 years old, gifted, two-footed, versatile and can win any match on his own. A potential steal at an initial £30.3m — he could be worth five times that amount in three years.
What we’re saying now: After a frustrating start with injury, Cherki has fully justified the hype. Four goals and eight assists in his past 14 appearances, with 0.98 assists per 90 (double the next best in the league) and 6.73 goal-creating actions (second in the league behind team-mate Doku). More than the numbers, he is a footballer who warms your heart. Changing the game for City and their manager Pep Guardiola. That, coupled with the relative low fee, makes his signing the Premier League’s best transfer business of last summer.
